Go Hollywood with this Excerpt from Plot Twist by Bethany Turner


We are so excited to bring you this exclusive excerpt from Plot Twist by Bethany Turner!

About Plot Twist:

An aspiring screenwriter has a chance encounter with an actor who could be the man of her dreams. Over the next ten years, she’ll write the story . . . but will he end up being the star?

February 4, 2003, promises to be a typical day for Olivia Ross—a greeting card writer whose passion project is a screenplay of her own. But after she and a handsome actor have a magical meet-cute in a coffee shop, they make a spontaneous pact: in ten years, after they’ve found the success they’re just sure they’re going to achieve, they’ll return to the coffeehouse to partner up and make a film together. The only problem? Olivia neglected to get the stranger’s name. But she doesn’t forget his face—or the date.

Every February 4 for the next ten years, Olivia has a day full of coincidences and ironies. As men come and go and return to her life, she continues to write, but still wonders about the guy from the coffee shop—the nameless actor she’s almost certain has turned out to be Hamish MacDougal, now a famous A-lister and Hollywood leading man.

But a lot can happen in ten years, and while waiting for the curtain to rise on her fate, the true story of Olivia’s life is being written—and if she’s not careful, she’ll completely miss the real-life romantic comedy playing out right before her eyes.

Frolic-Exclusive Excerpt:

February 4, 2005

I went to see Magnum Opus Phantasm, the movie version, on February 3, 2005. Fi made me go. I hated musicals, but she loved them. I mean, I suppose I didn’t hate all musicals, but the ones I liked were a little more obscure, and usually off-Broadway. They usually didn’t get big-screen adaptations. Fi, on the other hand, was a mainstream Broadway purist. Everything from West Side Story to Miss Saigon to Wicked . . . the bigger, the better. Magnum Opus Phantasm was right up her alley.

I just could never get into the randomness of the singing and dancing. I didn’t mind A Chorus Line. Yes, there was a ton of singing and dancing, but they were singers and dancers auditioning for a musical. The singing and dancing made sense. Les Misérables? Not so much. “It’s the eve of our first battle in the French Revolution! Sing and dance with me, won’t you?” Huh? No, thanks.

When Fi was a little girl, her family would fly from Boston to New York to see Broadway shows all the time. Just for the day, or the weekend. They took me with them on a few occasions, and usually I was miserable the entire time. At least while the show was going. I did, however, love New York. I loved the food, the skyscrapers, the people. I had a fascination with the subway, despite the fact that the Mitchells were not subway people. I would stare longingly each time we passed a station entrance, and I would watch the people going down the steps and coming up. I loved watching the people. You saw every type of person when you spent a weekend in New York. And there were a few places—probably lots of places, but I only knew of a few—where you could hear the subway beneath you as you walked. There, near Central Park, people could hear, if only they would listen. I thought that was magical.

But the shows? Not my thing. I thought Cats was the worst. I’d thought the title was a metaphor—for what, I didn’t know—so when I saw the show was actually made up of a bunch of cats singing, dancing, and playing in garbage, I was disappointed beyond measure. Fiona’s mother thought I was an ingrate for liking the prostitute cat, Grizabella, while Mr. Mitchell insisted I was mistaken. She couldn’t have been a prostitute, he believed. They wouldn’t have put that in a family-friendly musical. Fi and I giggled about it when they weren’t around and wondered what show they had been watching. For years after that, whenever Mr. and Mrs. Mitchell were oblivious to whatever scheme or machinations Fiona and I were concocting right under their noses, we would call it Grizabellaing.

Anyway, all of that is to say Fi dragged me to Magnum Opus Phantasm kicking and screaming. I knew I would hate it. Yes, it was based on a classic piece of French literature, and yes, in some ways the singing made sense, seeing as it took place in the context of an opera house and all. Still, I remained convinced that whatever virtue it possessed would be beaten out of it in its Hollywood adaptation, brought to you by the same team who produced Coyote Ugly.

“But the Phantasm is just your type of guy, Liv,” Fi declared, continuing our argument as we took our seats, popcorn in hand. “He’s melodramatic and brooding, and oh so serious. He’ll never go for the easy laugh or the appealing turn of phrase, that one. You may be in for a treat. I have a sneaking suspicion you’re really going to love this one.”

I didn’t. As expected, I hated it. I actually dozed off a couple of times. But whenever the Phantasm himself was onscreen, I was somewhat mesmerized. Not in an attraction sort of way, and certainly not in an I’m-enjoying-this-movie sort of way, but in a “Where have I seen that guy?” sort of way. Also, perhaps, in a the-people-who-made-this-movie-should-be-exiled-to-a-leper-colony sort of way.

“Who plays the Phantasm?” I leaned over and whispered as a scene at a masquerade ball droned on and on.

“Hamish MacDougal. He’s super cute without the mask.”

Never heard of him. “What’s he been in, besides this?”

Fi turned to me and whispered through gritted teeth, “Shut up. You’re ruining the magic!”

For me, the magic was that it finally ended.

The story continues in Plot Twist by Bethany Turner.

About the Author:

Bethany Turner has been writing since the second grade, when she won her first writing award for explaining why, if she could have lunch with any person throughout history, she would choose John Stamos. She stands by this decision. Bethany now writes pop culture-infused rom-coms for a new generation of readers who crave fiction that tackles the thorny issues of life with humor and insight. She lives in Southwest Colorado with her husband, whom she met in the nineties in a chat room called Disco Inferno. As sketchy as it sounds, it worked out pretty well in this case, and they are now the proud parents of two teenagers. 

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. 

Enjoyed this post?

Frolic F Logo



48 thoughts on “Go Hollywood with this Excerpt from Plot Twist by Bethany Turner”

    1. Roberta Brinkley

      As a ‘senior citizen’ who has been reading romance novels for years, Bethany’s romcoms are a delightful read. I’ve introduced her books to my family and friends who like a refreshing new voice in their library.

  1. I’m a die-hard Bethany Turner fan & can’t wait to read “Plot Twist” Thank you for posting this excerpt to get us even more excited about the book!

  2. I was excited for this book before this excpert, now….I’m really excited. Let me go pre-order my copy!

  3. Can not wait for this book! I’m a fan of the author and her RomCom books are laugh out loud funny!

  4. I’ve been waiting for this to come out and it promises to be worth the wait! Bethany Turner is one of my favorite authors!

  5. Bethany’s books pull you right into the story, as if you are sitting there listening to her tell it. So excited for this book to come out!

  6. Bethany Turner is the Queen of pop culture, and her rom-coms are fabulous – funny with heart and substance. I can’t wait to read the rest of Plot Twist!!

  7. So looking forward to this book! Bethany Turner always writes such fun, quirky books. Love the excerpt!

  8. Caitlyn Santi

    I adore Bethany Turner’s books! I got to read an early copy of this one and absolutely loved it!

  9. I’m looking forward to reading this book. Bethany’s other books are great, so I know this one will be too.

  10. Ooooo! Another Bethany Turner rom-com! Loved this excerpt and looking forward to a new intriguing story. (Though Max still holds my heart, we’ll see about this mystery man.)

  11. I have read every single book by Bethany, she had me hooked with “The Secret Life of Sarah Hollenbeck” (her debut). She introduced me to Inspirational Rom- Com and I can’t get enough of her writing!

    I’m beyond excited for “Plot Twist” 🙂

  12. Teri DiVincenzo

    I cannot even wait for the rest…although I may still be a **little bit** in love with Max from Hadley Beckett’s Next Dish!

  13. I have been so anxious and excited to read this book. Looking forward to it! Love Bethany Turner’s novels.

    1. I’ve already pre-ordered “Plot Twist,” based on how much I loved this author’s previous book, “The Secret Life of Sarah Hollenbeck!” I can’t wait to read this! Bethany Turner’s books are very entertaining!

  14. Oh my goodness, I can’t wait for this story! I’m feeling in a throw-back Hollywood type mood. (And the cover is the cutest )

  15. I am a huge fan of Bethany (not like stalker-level, but you know what I mean) so I am very excited for this latest installment. I read her last book in less than a week, which is quite a feat for me since I get easily — what was I saying. Oh, right. Looking forward to this book!

  16. Daphne Erhardt

    Love Bethany Turner and all her books. Can’t wait for Plot Twist, I know it will be just as amazing as all her others.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

About The Author


Favorite YA Book Series that Are Coming to an End in Early 2021


10 Historical Series I Would Love to See Adapted

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top