Moulin Rouge (2001)
My Score: 10/10
This is the one to beat for me. Moulin Rouge is the film we can directly credit for the numerous other musical movies of the 2000’s. And if you’re wondering whether it’s still good, the answer is a resounding YES.
What makes this movie musical so successful? At the time of its release, a great deal of its success could be attributed to its daring creativity, original ideas, and the total shock that a cinematic jukebox musical could be so entertaining in the new millennium.
All of those factors are still true, but as I compare Moulin Rouge to all the films that came afterwards and tried to capitalize on its success, one major quality contributes to its perfect score.
Moulin Rouge’s use of color, sound, music and drama capture what it’s like to sit in a theater and watch a live musical. The frenetic energy, fast-cuts that pivot your attention, and overwhelming earnestness every time characters burst into song creates the adrenaline rush that you might get from an actual night watching a stage show.
On the flip side, movies of the 2000’s that tried to capture the magic of actual existing Broadway shows often failed, because the straightforward re-telling of the musical format didn’t accurately use film language to connect (but more on that in a bit…)
So yes. I will love Moulin Rouge until my dying day. 😉